american idol review for tonight
since i put so much effort into my weekly review that i send to other dedicated ai fans, i thought i should share it here as well.
okay, let's just say that i LOVED this night. i adore that kind of music.
chris: i loved it. it gave me goosebumps. i mean, it was excellent. that's a hard song to sing because everyone loves louie so well and i wasn't even comparing it at all. loved. please won't you acknowledge now that he's pretty dang good?!
paris: i would have been surprised if paris didn't excel tonight. i love her singing this music. excellent, just excellent.
taylor: yes, i loved this too. i agree with the judges that the beginning may have been a bit safe/boring but that ending was so so so good.
elliot: you know i love elliot. you must know that. and i was expecting him to do a really great job with this music. and he did well. it's just that he didn't blow me away. i might be a little, tiny bit with simon on this one. but i love elliot!
kellie: uck. i think she started okay but there were some pretty horrible notes in there.
ace: i was a bit surprised. first, i actually hoped he had cut his stupid hair. yes, i think he did very good to begin with but when he went to that falsetto, i hated the rest of the song. i just can't stand it. and the other tones he affected after it were not so hot for me either.
katharine: i love katharine too. and i really expected her to do super well tonight. unfortunately, i did not agree with the judges at all. this definitely wasn't good for me. it could be possible that i'm against her performance because that is one of my most favorite songs ever and i just did not like her version. i didn't like the way she held the notes. i think she could have done it better.
so, i can't exactly figure out my bottom three. i would definitely put kellie there, no question. and i hate to say it, but i think elliot will be there again (i really really don't want him to be but i think that's just how it will be). and you know i'm ready for ace to leave but i don't know if he will after tonight. i would put katharine in the bottom as well but i'll probably be wrong about that because the judges loved her so well. if it was just based on tonight's performances, i would say kellie should go.
wow, that was a long review!
okay, let's just say that i LOVED this night. i adore that kind of music.
chris: i loved it. it gave me goosebumps. i mean, it was excellent. that's a hard song to sing because everyone loves louie so well and i wasn't even comparing it at all. loved. please won't you acknowledge now that he's pretty dang good?!
paris: i would have been surprised if paris didn't excel tonight. i love her singing this music. excellent, just excellent.
taylor: yes, i loved this too. i agree with the judges that the beginning may have been a bit safe/boring but that ending was so so so good.
elliot: you know i love elliot. you must know that. and i was expecting him to do a really great job with this music. and he did well. it's just that he didn't blow me away. i might be a little, tiny bit with simon on this one. but i love elliot!
kellie: uck. i think she started okay but there were some pretty horrible notes in there.
ace: i was a bit surprised. first, i actually hoped he had cut his stupid hair. yes, i think he did very good to begin with but when he went to that falsetto, i hated the rest of the song. i just can't stand it. and the other tones he affected after it were not so hot for me either.
katharine: i love katharine too. and i really expected her to do super well tonight. unfortunately, i did not agree with the judges at all. this definitely wasn't good for me. it could be possible that i'm against her performance because that is one of my most favorite songs ever and i just did not like her version. i didn't like the way she held the notes. i think she could have done it better.
so, i can't exactly figure out my bottom three. i would definitely put kellie there, no question. and i hate to say it, but i think elliot will be there again (i really really don't want him to be but i think that's just how it will be). and you know i'm ready for ace to leave but i don't know if he will after tonight. i would put katharine in the bottom as well but i'll probably be wrong about that because the judges loved her so well. if it was just based on tonight's performances, i would say kellie should go.
wow, that was a long review!
posted by kyledawn @ 10:35 PM
<< Home